Nesiya: Israel Programs for Israeli and American Teens
Safe and Secure Israel Programs

Kehillah 2007 Updates

August 5th, 2007 - Conflicting Visions:  A Jerusalem Exploration

Dear Nesiya Parents and Friends,

Shavuah tov! It has been a full and rich weekend here in Jerusalem for Nesiya 2007. Last Thursday your children participated in an engaging, diverse and thought-provoking seminar on the political situation in Israel. After each group conducted an opening session on Wednesday night, which provided an overview to the conflict, the participants were presented a menu of speaker and tour options to 'design-their-own' politics day based on their personal interests and curiosity. The first session on Thursday offered a variety of politically-oriented Jerusalem tours, from a tour focusing on the separation barrier, to a visit to Abu Tor, a mixed Arab-Jewish neighborhood, to an historical overview of this contested city through visits to key geographical points. Participants reported gaining a deeper understanding of the complex role Jerusalem has in the conflict. A few of the Israeli participants, who have lived here for their entire lives and toured within a few miles of their homes, shared that they saw a perspective of the city they'd never known before!

The next two sessions allowed participants to choose from speakers representing the breadth of Israel's political spectrum. The second session included presentations by Rabbi Meir Schweiger, who shared his personal story about living in Efrat, a settlement in Gush Etzion; Mikhael Manekin, an IDF veteran, who spoke about the behavior of soldiers at checkpoints; and Rabbi Melissa Weintraub, who founded Encounter, an organization that aims to give Jewish Diaspora leaders exposure to Palestinian life.

The third session offered four options, including Ari Abramowitz, who recounted his experience in the Second Lebanon War last summer; Meir Indor, founder of the Almagor Terror Victims Association, who shared about the work he does with terror victims and the high cost of peace; Rami Elchanan and Aziz Abu Sarah, representatives of the Bereaved Families Forum who spoke of their own personal losses and how they have affected their subsequent choices and ideals of supporting peace, tolerance and reconciliation; and a tour of Ir David/Silwan, led by Asher Altshul, a Jerusalem archeologist.

The final session was a keynote presentation by Josh Teitelbaum, a leading scholar and consultant on Middle Eastern politics and history. Dr. Teitelbaum gave the participants the opportunity to ask any question they had about the conflict, and their insightful and challenging questions included such topics as the nuclear threat of Iraq, the morality of checkpoints, and the future of the peace process. At the end of the day, each group participated in a closing activity, giving them time to process the various speakers and think about where they stand on these difficult issues. Your children were thoughtful, sensitive, and articulate as they struggled with these questions.

Click here to see the full menu of options and more information about all of the speakers mentioned above.

Friday morning Kehillahs One and Two explored the natural side of the area by hiking through the Judean Hills. During their hikes they encountered ancient ruins as well as refreshing natural springs. Kehillah Three explored a number of Jerusalem neighborhoods, including Mea She'arim, Rehavia, Nachlaot, the Russian Compound, and the German Colony. All three groups were then given time on the famed Ben Yehuda Street to buy lunch and pick up a last few souvenirs!

Later on Friday, the groups returned to Beit Shmuel to prepare for Shabbat. Over the weeks, it has been remarkable to see them grapple with questions about pluralism, tolerance, and Judaism as they are becoming a strong and caring community, and this is never as evident as on Shabbat, when they help create an array of options appropriate for all members of the community. Friday evening and Saturday morning they had the opportunity to attend prayer services at the wide variety of synagogues Jerusalem has to offer (as well as at the Kotel) or to go for a Jerusalem walk.

Over the course of Shabbat there were a number of activities, most notably one on conflicting visions of the relationship of the Jewish people with the land of Israel and the ideal of a Jewish state. This activity was essentially a culmination of the previous weeks’ interactions with different segments of Israeli society and differing political views, and allowed participants to sum up their experiences within their own group communities. Participants read excerpts from a number of great Jewish and Israeli thinkers, philosophers, sages and leaders, reflecting a broad spectrum of opinions, attitudes and outlooks. They then used the texts as tools to help define and compare their own beliefs and thoughts. They were also given ample time to question each other's views and to discuss the ramifications of realizing that good friends might harbor opposing opinions.

Saturday night featured an incredible and lively participant-organized talent show, filled with original songs, poetry readings, dance and music performances, acrobatics, and puppet shows presented by participants and staff. It was a special evening for participants to share and appreciate each other's talents and passions.

This morning Kehillahs One and Two toured the Jerusalem neighborhoods, while Kehillah Three did activities at Beit Shmuel. For lunch, the participants partook in a favorite Jerusalem activity: shopping at the shuk (market). Your children got to experience the bustle and excitement of wandering through the alleys of Machane Yehuda, Jerusalem's outdoor market, where they could purchase anything from the fresh, exotic fruit to gooey chocolate ruggalach to souvenir Shabbat candles, all amidst the endless din of stall owners shouting the price of tomatoes and rabbis encouraging men to lay t'fillin. The shuk is a true Jerusalem adventure!

The groups drove to Ein Gedi this afternoon, where they'll be based for the remainder of the program. They will spend the next few days working on their personal projects. Tonight's final project introductory workshop will encourage the participants to reflect on the wide variety of experiences they've had this summer, and to begin thinking about the themes they would like to focus on in their presentations. Tomorrow a team of five arts educators arrive in Ein Gedi to meet with individual students as advisors and consultants for the personal projects. We look forward to appreciating your children's creative expressions later this week!

Warmly,
Mollie